Feud for Thought
The Last Five Years is the end-all of breakup musicals
The Riverfront Times

Two-thirds of the way through The Last Five Years, the 80-minute,
no-intermission musical that is receiving its local premiere in the
Emerson Studio Theatre by the Repertory Theatre of St. Louis,
something highly unusual begins to happen: Thought becomes palpable.
You can actually feel the audience thinking.

They're thinking about Jamie, the college student whose meteoric rise
as a novelist sours his budding relationship with Kathy, a struggling
young actress for whom success is more elusive. The audience is
fervently asking why Jamie is so self-consumed and why Kathy can't
control her wasteful insecurities. "No one will understand," Jamie
sings as the show begins its decrescendo. But judging from the energy
that emanated from the intensely involved opening-night audience,
this is a story that too many people understand only too well.

All writers draw on personal experiences, but The Last Five Years
somehow goes deeper than that. For Jason Robert Brown, creating this
two-character musical provided a purging of his own past, a catharsis
for the missteps in his own marriage. Sure, there's been some
dissembling (Jamie is an author, not a composer), but there's no
self-indulgence here, no self-justification. On the contrary, the
piece is artful. The glorious score -- tender, sad, sensitive,
playful and compulsively melodic -- is destined to find a permanent
niche in the American musical-theater library.

The evening begins at the end. Kathy is alone with her demons. She
blames Jamie for the dissolution of a marriage that, to her way of
thinking, died only because he decreed it so. But as soon as Jamie
appears, the time frame leaps back five years to their first date,
and we meet a young man obsessed with the notion of loving someone
like Kathy. For the next fourteen songs (dialogue is incidental; the
show is almost completely sung), the plot tinkers with time: Jamie
springs forward five years to inevitable carnage; Kathy reverses the
story as she works her way back to the hope and promise of that
wondrous first date. The only time the two characters intersect is on
their wedding day.

Though their doomed story is muddied by false hopes, missed
opportunities and imagined slights, the production itself is a
miracle of direct simplicity. There's no amplification; instead we
hear two pure voices beautifully supported by cello (Natasha
Rubinstein), violin (Adrian Walker) and piano (musical director David
Geist, who also deserves thanks for the witty orchestrations). Under
the consummate direction of John Ruocco, the evening is perfectly
calibrated to the intimate studio space.

Ruocco has not rendered a replica of the 1992 off-Broadway edition.
 From beginning to end (or end to beginning), the entire show has been
reconceived; everything here is new. The clean, spare scenic design
by Narelle Sissons amounts to little more than a long roll of photo
paper (as if to suggest that these musical vignettes are snapshots
from the past). The ultimate effect is a staging as innocent and
pristine as if the musical were being performed in Eden.

As Jamie, Anthony Holds excels in his most challenging moments. "The
Schmuel Song," in which Jamie concocts an elaborate and somewhat
dense story in order to give Kathy her Christmas gift, is the show's
toughest piece, but Holds attacks it head-on. He's also not put off
by the fact that Jamie becomes increasingly unsympathetic as the
evening progresses. To the contrary, Holds manages to find an almost
serene dignity in self-destruction.

Although Kathy is often garbed in bland beiges, Kate Baldwin brings
an array of colors to her wrenching portrayal. An unthinking tug at
her sweater, a quick sip of wine, can tell us all we need to know
about Kathy's precarious condition. The actress delivers wonderful
surprises all night long. (Watch how she holds the final note on the
lyric "Then he smiles" long enough to draw an imaginary happy face
with her foot.) Baldwin's primly bravura performance is defined by
humor, humanity and unfathomable hurt.

It's possible that not everyone will tap into every single thing
that's happening onstage. (It's not all that clear, for instance,
that in one scene the set's sole chair is being used as a rowboat in
Central Park.) But the occasional confusions pass quickly; what
lingers is the overwhelming sense that The Last Five Years is a
unique and fascinating theater experiment. As staged by the Studio
Rep, this minimalist musical is a large-scale triumph.